Casey Bakes: Fresh Pies, Cakes & Sweet Treats in Hilliard

About Casey's Home Bakes

Smiling woman presenting trays of cinnamon rolls with green icing.

Casey's Home Bakes

Hello!! I'm Casey Martin, owner and baker of my home based company, Casey's Home Bakes. I love the thought of re inviting people's taste buds to memories of a favorite pie or cake family and friends can gather and share good times, good fellowship, and great memories!

Assorted pies in white boxes with green ribbons on a wooden table.

Fresh, fresh FRESH

My pies and cakes are made fresh to order. Because they are fresh, as well as the crusts being handmade, I need 2-3 days advance notice to bake your sweet treat. These pies, cakes and cookies are baked with the ingredients listed on each label, sprinkled in prayer and my love for baking memories for you, friends and family.

Two people relaxing with cake slices and a remote on a couch.

What memory can I bake for you?

There are many dietary restrictions out there and I am working diligently to accommodate. Because I bake your pie fresh, for you, I am able to take on some unique needs you may have. Some needs, such as nut allergens, I am able to accommodate. Stay tuned!! Developing a Gluten Free crust as well as Low Sugar options with my pies!!

Order some sweet memories today!

Slice of Oreo cheesecake with chocolate drizzle and whipped cream.

Oreo Cream Pie $27

Coconut Cream Pie $28

Dutch Apple Pie $27

A freshly baked crumb-topped pie on a wooden surface.

Dutch Apple Pie $27

Coconut Cream Pie $28

Dutch Apple Pie $27

A coconut cream pie topped with toasted coconut flakes.

Coconut Cream Pie $28

Coconut Cream Pie $28

Coconut Cream Pie $28

A slice of pecan pie on a white plate outdoors.

Pecan Pie $27

Pecan Pie $27

Coconut Cream Pie $28

A creamy white cake with piped frosting and a small carrot decoration on top.

Carrot Cake

Pecan Pie $27

Coconut Cake

6 inch or 9 inch 2 layers

A creamy white coconut cake with frosting and coconut flakes on a plate.

Coconut Cake

Pecan Pie $27

Coconut Cake

6 inch or 9 inch 3 layers

A creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust on a wooden stand.

Casey's Classic Cheesecake $60

Casey's Classic Cheesecake $60

Casey's Classic Cheesecake $60

***limited quantity

Close-up of a slice of yellow cake with white frosting on a plate.

Shelled Lemon Pound Cake $38

Casey's Classic Cheesecake $60

Casey's Classic Cheesecake $60

Chocolate cream pie topped with whipped cream and chocolate chips.

Chocolate Cream Pie $27

Casey's Classic Cheesecake $60

Chocolate Cream Pie $27

A slice of gooey pecan pie with a golden crust on a white plate.

Chocolate Pecan Pie

Creamy Lemon Pie (option w/ Blueberry or w / Strawberry

Chocolate Cream Pie $27

German Chocolate Pie

Creamy Lemon Pie (option w/ Blueberry or w / Strawberry

Creamy Lemon Pie (option w/ Blueberry or w / Strawberry

Creamy Lemon Pie (option w/ Blueberry or w / Strawberry

Creamy Lemon Pie (option w/ Blueberry or w / Strawberry

Creamy Lemon Pie (option w/ Blueberry or w / Strawberry

Ask me what can be made GF or DF or both!

Close-up of a golden-brown lattice crust pie.

Apple Pie $26

Chocolate PB Pie $27

Key Lime Pie $26

Slice of key lime pie with whipped cream and lime garnish on a blue plate.

Key Lime Pie $26

Chocolate PB Pie $27

Key Lime Pie $26

A creamy peanut butter and chocolate pie with whipped cream and crunchy toppings.

Chocolate PB Pie $27

Chocolate PB Pie $27

Chocolate PB Pie $27

Slice of cherry pie on a white plate with decorative cups in the background.

Cherry Pie $27

Deviled “Eggs” Cookies

Chocolate PB Pie $27

Mint chocolate chip dessert slice topped with chocolate drizzle and cookie half.

Mint Oreo Cream Pie

Deviled “Eggs” Cookies

Deviled “Eggs” Cookies

Heart-shaped cookies with frosting on a green plate.

Deviled “Eggs” Cookies

Deviled “Eggs” Cookies

Deviled “Eggs” Cookies

Close-up of hot cross buns in a foil tray.

Hot Cross Buns $10/ 6

Fresh Baked Dinner Rolls $14/ doz

Fresh Baked Dinner Rolls $14/ doz

Freshly baked biscuits in a plaid cloth-lined basket.

Fresh Baked Dinner Rolls $14/ doz

Fresh Baked Dinner Rolls $14/ doz

Fresh Baked Dinner Rolls $14/ doz

What memory can I Bake for you!!! NEW to CHB’s!!!

Text to 614-219-9752 for ordering

Chocolate drip cake topped with cookies and cream frosting swirls.

Peanut Butter Oreo Crunch Cake

$75

Chocolate cake topped with fresh raspberries and chocolate frosting.

Chocolate Raspberry filled Cake

Full $70

A slice of crumb-topped apple pie with caramel drizzle on a white plate.

Hot Buttered Rum Apple Pie

$30

Decorative chocolate-covered cookies with white and dark drizzle.

Dark and White Chocolate Dipped Oreos

$21/ half doz

Round white chocolate treats with black drizzle and red sprinkles on a plate.

Peanut Butter Dipped Oreos

$21/ half doz

Just a little dab of PB in the middle!!

A chocolate cake with white icing decoration in a foil tray.

Ding Dong Cake

$24

Three cinnamon sugar muffins topped with swirl frosting on a white plate.

Snickerdoodle Muffins

$15 for 1/2 doz

Freshly baked berry cobbler in a foil tray on a wooden surface.

Blackberry Cobbler

Full $40/ 1/2 $20

Elegant white cake with cream swirls and red velvet crumbs on top.

Red Velvet Cake

Strawberry cake with yellow frosting and decorative swirls.

Lemon Strawberry Cake

Raspberry Chip Pie

Creamy Lemon Pie

$25

Marbled Choclate Covered Strawberry Cake with Strawberry filling

$65

GF/DF Vanilla/ Vanilla “Butter”cream icing

$65

Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie

Cherry Pie

$25

Lemon Meringue Pie

$27

Blueberry Pie

$25

Apple Pie

$25

Snickers Brownie

$24

Something NEW being baked up SOON!!!